Madame Fourcade’s Secret War, by Lynne Olson

Madame_

I recently posted about Sonia Purnell’s excellent A Woman of No Importance about Baltimore-born Virginia Hall who became one of the first British spies in German-occupied France during WWII. She organised Resistance units and provided critical intelligence to the Allies through the Special Operations Executive (SOE), a secret UK intelligence agency formed in 1940.

I hadn’t planned on reading Olson’s book about Marie-Madeleine Fourcade who also ran a Resistance operation in France, supplying critical information to MI6, the UK’s Special Intelligence Service. Then my book club chose it.

When her partner was arrested in 1941, Fourcade became head of Alliance, a Resistance network she had helped build. Under her dedicated leadership, Alliance expanded throughout both Occupied France and Vichy France (where Hall was based), providing most notably a 55-foot-long map of the beaches and roads along the Normandy coast, showing German guns and fortifications, an invaluable aid to the Allies on D-Day.

The story includes escapes, tragic losses, and daring exploits. There’s lots of great information, very detailed.

What I missed was a sense of Fourcade herself. In Purnell’s book we get a close view of Hall, what makes her tick, how she responds to her experiences. In Olson’s book it is more “just the facts, Ma’am.” For example, Fourcade’s hardly ever seeing her young children during the war years for security reasons makes sense, and she didn’t know they’d lost their adult protector and had to make their way alone through war-torn France. But surely she felt a complex swirl of emotions, constantly changing, eating away at her resolution to stay on as head of Alliance. None of that comes through.

One thing that struck me strongly in both books was the infighting. I’m not just talking about Vichy versus Resistance. In the UK, SOE and MI6 were fiercely competitive, trying to deny each other resources, sometimes even sabotaging each other’s efforts. Similarly de Gaulle’s Free French group refused to help Virginia Hall’s group or other French fighters and eventually broke with MI6 as well. Also, one of Roosevelt’s conditions for the U.S. joining the war was that de Gaulle not be in charge of the French forces. He chose instead someone else who was not respected by the French military, making the North Africa campaign a debacle. They were supposed to all be on the same side! It’s a miracle the Allies won the war.

Of course, I see the same thing going on in politics today, in country after country. Too many people who are supposed to be serving the country and doing the best thing for its citizens are choosing instead to maximise their own power and fortune over that of their fellows, not caring how much devastation they cause for their country and its people.

I suppose I shouldn’t be surprised. When I started work in an office, I quickly realised that I could divide my colleagues into those who wanted to do good work and those who only wanted to get ahead. It’s been a useful distinction ever since. Not that I’m entirely cynical. I recently learned of a real Lord of the Flies where the shipwrecked boys marooned on a Pacific Island worked together and took care of each other for 15 months. And we are beginning to learn that cooperation has been just as longstanding and crucial in our societies as competition.

I’m encouraged by Fourcade’s selfless devotion to her country and to the operatives she’d collected. No wonder she was designated as a hero by de Gaulle at the end of WWII.

Are you reading stories—fiction or nonfiction—about courage and selflessness? Suggest a few!

3 thoughts on “Madame Fourcade’s Secret War, by Lynne Olson

  1. Elizabeth says:

    Re not learning more about Fourcade’s thoughts and emotions. This is not a work of fiction and the material to reconstruct her thoughts doesn’t exist—as Fourcade wanted it. Why should we think we have a right to know, rather than respect the privacy she wanted?

    • barbara says:

      Thank you for your comment and for reminding me that I meant to add (as I’ve said often on this blog) that I am opposed to the use of real people as fictional characters, attributing actions and emotions to them that cannot be substantiated. As Milan Kundera wrote so movingly in Immortality, the person who controls our legacy after our death can change the facts and meaning of our lives on a whim. I agree that we have a responsibility to protect the privacy of the dead.

      As stated, the purpose of this blog is to write about the books I read from my point of view as a writer, what I can learn about writing from them. Reading this book almost back-to-back with the Purnell book, I was struck by the difference. I found the Purnell book fascinating, suspenseful, and engaging. I could hardly bear to stop reading. This book felt flat to me, and I struggled to finish it.

      The immediate difference is in the main character. Fourcade is a cipher in this book, seemingly unchanged at the end of her ordeals from the person she was at the beginning. Of course that can’t be true. And I recognise that in the nonfiction I’ve been reading, Moorehead, Lawson, and Purnell had access to personal documents by their protagonists and/or those near them to provide intimate details. Certainly, where such information is available, as it is here in the testimony of the man who rebelled against being subordinate to a woman and broke up that part of Alliance, it is moving.

      A difference I didn’t mention because I no longer have the books in front of me to quote from is the use of techniques to create suspense. It seems to me that Olson makes less use of these. Another landing, another map, another change of house: things happen but there are fewer dramatic scenes. The ones that are there, like Fourcade’s escape from prison, are excellent.

      Certainly this book is an important historical document. I learned about Fourcade’s activities, and more about what MI6 and Alliance did. And I learned a bit about what to watch out for in my own writing.

  2. ChrisM says:

    Madame Fourcade’s Secret War looks like a great book to read.

    Chris
    Owner CEL Financial Services
    IRS Registered Tax Preparer
    Registered bonded California CTEC Tax Preparer
    https://incometaxprepfillmore.com

Leave a Reply to Elizabeth Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>